How do I choose a metal drill bit?

Drilling metal with the wrong bit means slow work, broken bits, or ruined parts. This wastes time, money, and causes major frustration in your workshop.

To choose a metal drill bit, consider the metal's hardness and the hole's precision. High-Speed Steel (HSS) bits suit softer metals, while cobalt or carbide bits are better for harder, tougher materials.

In my shop, Allied Metal, we do a lot of CNC machining, and drilling holes is a fundamental part of probably 90% of the jobs that come through. Whether it's for a simple bracket or a complex aerospace component for an engineer like David, using the correct drill bit isn't just a suggestion – it's essential. My experience has taught me that choosing the right metal drill bit depends on the hardness of the metal and the precision required for the task. You can have the best CNC machine in the world, but with the wrong bit, you're just making scrap or fighting an uphill battle. High-speed steel (HSS) or cobalt bits are generally the best choices for durability and clean results in most metalworking projects. Getting this right from the start saves a lot of headaches and ensures the quality of the final product. Let's drill down into the details.

---

How Do I Know What Drill Bit to Use for Metal?

Starting a metal drilling project but unsure which bit to grab from the rack? Using the wrong one can quickly lead to a frustrating and unproductive experience.

Identify the type and hardness of the metal you're drilling. Softer metals like aluminum allow for standard HSS bits, while harder metals demand cobalt or carbide bits for effective penetration.

Diving Deeper into Initial Material Considerations

The very first step before you even think about the drill bit itself is to understand the material you're about to drill into. This is something I always stress to my team and to clients like David. Different metals behave in vastly different ways when you try to cut them.

Identify the Metal Type

• Is it a ferrous metal¹ (contains iron, like steel) or a non-ferrous metal (like aluminum, copper, brass)? This is a basic but important distinction.
• Within steels, is it a low-carbon (mild) steel, a medium-carbon steel, an alloy steel, stainless steel, or a hardened tool steel? Each has unique drilling characteristics.
• For non-ferrous metals, common types include aluminum alloys, copper alloys (brass, bronze), magnesium, and titanium.

Assess Material Hardness

• Hardness is a primary factor. Softer metals like aluminum or mild steel are relatively easy to drill. Harder metals like stainless steel, hardened tool steel, or exotic alloys like Inconel present a much greater challenge.
• You can often find hardness information (e.g., Rockwell, Brinell, Vickers) on material specification sheets. If not, a quick file test can give a rough idea: if a standard file easily bites into the metal, it's relatively soft. If the file skates off, it's hard.
• My insight is key here: the metal's hardness directly dictates your drill bit material choice. Trying to drill hardened steel with a basic HSS bit meant for wood or soft metal will just dull or break the bit instantly.

Consider Work-Hardening Tendencies

• Some metals, notably certain stainless steels (like 304) and some nickel alloys, have a strong tendency to work-harden². This means that the act of drilling itself can make the material at the bottom of the hole harder, making further penetration increasingly difficult.
• For these materials, you need a drill bit that stays sharp and allows for consistent feed pressure to "get under" the work-hardened layer. Stopping and starting or letting the bit rub without cutting will make the problem worse.

Understanding these aspects of your workpiece material is the foundation for making an informed drill bit selection. It prevents a lot of wasted time, broken tools, and poorly drilled holes.

---

How Do You Choose the Right Drill Bit for the Job?

Knowing your metal is step one, but drill bits come in many types. How do you match bit features to your material and desired hole quality?

Choose the right drill bit by matching its material (HSS, cobalt, carbide), coating, point angle, and flute design to the specific metal and application for optimal performance and hole quality.

Diving Deeper into Drill Bit Characteristics for Metal

Once you know what metal you're drilling, you can start looking at the drill bit itself. Several features of a drill bit determine its suitability for different metals and applications. As an engineer, David would appreciate these details for specifying tooling.

Drill Bit Material

This is arguably the most important factor after identifying your workpiece material.

• High-Speed Steel (HSS): The workhorse for general-purpose drilling in softer metals like aluminum, brass, copper, mild steel, and plastics. It's affordable and offers decent heat resistance. My insight points to HSS as a good general choice.
• Cobalt (HSCO or HSS-Co): These are HSS bits with 5% to 8% cobalt added. Cobalt significantly increases heat resistance and hardness, making these bits excellent for drilling harder and tougher materials like stainless steel, cast iron, titanium, and other high-strength alloys. They last longer than standard HSS in these demanding applications.
• Solid Carbide (or Carbide-Tipped): Carbide is extremely hard and can withstand very high cutting temperatures. This makes carbide drill bits ideal for drilling very hard or abrasive materials like hardened steels, high-nickel alloys, composites, or for high-production drilling in cast iron. However, carbide is also more brittle than HSS or cobalt, so it requires a rigid setup and steady feed to prevent chipping or breakage.

Drill Bit Coatings

Coatings can further enhance a drill bit's performance and lifespan:

• Titanium Nitride (TiN): A common gold-colored coating that increases hardness and provides some lubricity, extending tool life in general-purpose applications, primarily on HSS bits.
• Titanium Carbonitride (TiCN): Harder than TiN, offering better wear resistance, especially in abrasive materials.
• Titanium Aluminum Nitride (TiAlN or AlTiN): Excellent for high-heat applications, as the aluminum forms a protective aluminum oxide layer at high temperatures. Great for drilling hard steels and stainless steels, often used on cobalt and carbide bits.
• Black Oxide: A less expensive surface treatment that provides some corrosion resistance and helps retain cutting fluid. Offers minimal performance increase compared to an uncoated bit but is better than bare HSS.

Drill Point Angle

• 118-degree point: A common angle suitable for softer metals like aluminum, mild steel, and plastics. Easier to regrind.
• 135-degree point (with split point): Better for harder, tougher metals. The flatter angle reduces the thrust required to penetrate the material, and the split point helps prevent the bit from "walking" (wandering off center) when starting the hole. The split point is a huge help for self-centering, which is critical for precision.

Flute Design

• The spiral grooves³ (flutes) evacuate chips from the hole. Standard flute designs work for most metals. For softer, gummier materials like some aluminums, a faster spiral (higher helix angle⁴) can help with chip ejection. For harder materials, a slower spiral might provide more strength at the cutting edge.

Considering these characteristics will guide you to a much more effective drill bit choice.

---

What Specific Drill Bit Do I Need for Different Metals?

You understand general features, but what are concrete recommendations? Which drill bit type is best for common metals like steel, aluminum, or stainless steel?

For mild steel and aluminum, HSS bits often suffice. For stainless steel or harder alloy steels, cobalt (HSS-Co) bits are recommended. For very hard or abrasive materials, consider carbide bits.

Diving Deeper into Matching Bits to Metals

Let's get specific. While there are always nuances, here are some general recommendations for drill bit types based on common metals that I often see in projects David might work on, or that come through my shop at Allied Metal.

Drilling Softer Metals

• Aluminum: Aluminum is soft and gummy, and it conducts heat well.
  • Recommended Bit: Standard High-Speed Steel (HSS) bits work well. A 118° or 135° point angle can be used. A faster spiral (high helix) flute design can help with chip ejection. Using a lubricant like kerosene or specialized aluminum cutting fluid is crucial to prevent chips from welding to the bit.
  • Coating: TiN coating can be beneficial for longevity.
• Brass and Copper: These are also relatively soft and easy to machine.
  • Recommended Bit: HSS bits are generally fine. A 118° point is common. For brass, sometimes a slightly "dubbed" or zero rake cutting edge is used to prevent the bit from grabbing or digging in.
• Mild Steel (Low-Carbon Steel): The most common type of steel.
  • Recommended Bit: Good quality HSS bits are usually sufficient. A 118° point angle is common for general work, but a 135° split point is better for starting holes without a center punch.
  • Coating: TiN or Black Oxide can improve performance and life.

Drilling Harder and Tougher Metals

• Stainless Steel (e.g., 304, 316): Stainless steel is tough, abrasive, and work-hardens easily.
  • Recommended Bit: Cobalt (HSS-Co) bits are strongly recommended. They resist the heat generated and stay sharp longer. A 135° split point is essential to prevent walking and to penetrate the work-hardened surface.
  • Coating: TiAlN or AlTiN coatings are excellent here due to their heat resistance.
  • Technique: Use a slower RPM, firm and consistent feed pressure, and a good quality cutting fluid formulated for stainless steel. Avoid letting the bit dwell or rub.
• Alloy Steels & Hardened Steels (e.g., 4140 pre-hard, tool steels in annealed state): These are harder and tougher than mild steel.
  • Recommended Bit: Cobalt (HSS-Co) bits are the primary choice. For very hard steels (e.g., above 40 HRC), solid carbide drill bits might be necessary, but they require a very rigid setup.
  • Point Angle: 135° split point.
  • Coating: TiAlN or similar high-performance coatings.
• Cast Iron: While not always extremely hard, cast iron is abrasive and produces fine, powdery chips.
  • Recommended Bit: HSS can work for softer grades, but Cobalt or Carbide bits will last much longer. A 118° or 135° point can be used.
  • Technique: Cast iron is often drilled dry, but air blast can help clear chips.

My insight about HSS and Cobalt being general best choices reflects this – HSS for the softer end, Cobalt for the harder end of common metals. Carbide is the specialist for extreme cases.

---

What Is Considered the Best Drill Bit for Metal Work Overall?

When you want top performance, durability, and clean holes, what's the ultimate "best" drill bit? Is there a single type that outshines all others for metal?

The "best" drill bit is job-specific, but for general high-performance metal work, cobalt (HSS-Co) bits with a 135° split point and a quality coating like TiAlN offer excellent versatility and durability.

Diving Deeper into "Best" for Purpose and Precision

While there isn't one single "best" drill bit for every conceivable metal drilling task, we can certainly talk about what constitutes a high-quality, versatile, and high-performing option for most common metalworking scenarios that someone like David or my team at Allied Metal would encounter. My insight points to HSS or Cobalt as generally the best choices, and I'd lean towards Cobalt for a broader range of "best performance."

Here's what makes a drill bit "best" for general metalwork, focusing on precision and efficiency:

Key Attributes of a "Best" General Metal Drill Bit:

1. Material: Cobalt (HSS-Co)

   • Cobalt bits (typically M35 with 5% cobalt or M42 with 8% cobalt) offer a superior balance of toughness, hardness, and heat resistance compared to standard HSS. This makes them suitable for a wider range of metals, from mild steels and aluminum up to stainless steels and other tough alloys. They maintain their edge sharpness longer at higher temperatures.

2. Point Geometry: 135° Split Point

   • This angle is better for harder materials as it requires less push (thrust force).
   • The split point design is crucial. It creates two additional cutting edges at the very tip, which allows the bit to self-center effectively. This prevents "walking" when starting a hole, leading to more accurately placed holes without needing a center punch mark (though center punching or center drilling is still good practice for high precision).

3. Quality Coating: TiAlN (Titanium Aluminum Nitride) or Similar

   • A coating like TiAlN provides a very hard surface, reduces friction, and acts as a thermal barrier. This significantly improves tool life and allows for slightly higher cutting speeds, especially in harder materials.

4. Precision Ground Flutes and Construction:

   • High-quality bits will have precisely ground flutes for efficient chip evacuation and overall dimensional accuracy. The web thickness and helix angle are also optimized.

Optimizing for Specific Tasks/Outcomes:

• Precision Hole Starting: For very accurate hole location, especially before using a larger drill, a center drill or a spotting drill (often made from HSS or Cobalt) is the "best" way to create a precise starting dimple.
• Achieving Tight Tolerance Hole Diameters: Standard twist drills create holes that are functional but may not be perfectly round or to an exact size. For high precision diameters, the "best" approach involves drilling slightly undersize, then following up with a reamer.
• Hole Size/Depth:
  • Jobber Length: Standard length, most common.
  • Screw Machine Length (Stub Length): Shorter and more rigid, good for reducing deflection and improving accuracy in shallow holes or when drilling in lathes or screw machines.
  • Taper Length / Long Drills: For deeper holes, but require care to prevent breakage and ensure chip evacuation.

So, while a premium M42 cobalt drill bit with a TiAlN coating and a 135° split point is an excellent all-around high-performer, the "best" always considers the specific task, material, and desired outcome. For David's work, having a good set of these cobalt bits would cover a vast majority of his metal drilling needs effectively.

---

Conclusion

Choosing the right metal drill bit means matching bit material, geometry, and coating to the specific metal and task. This ensures efficiency, precision, and tool longevity.

---